Crafting A Delicious Copycat Red Lobster Stuffed Mushrooms Recipe at Home

Sharing is caring!

Last updated on November 30th, 2023

Red Lobster Stuffed mushrooms recipe

Ah, the recipe for Red Lobster’s stuffed mushrooms – a tempting combination of seafood, cheese, spices, and vegetables loaded into a glorious mushroom cap. The idea of making the same kind of magic in the comforts of your kitchen got you tingling with excitement. Then let’s make these mushrooms sing!

Follow along as we guide you step-by-step through every ingredient, seasoning, and stuffing trick. And hey, you may find a couple of surprises thrown in there. So prepare yourself for a culinary journey and see how easy it is to bake these mushrooms until they’re golden and bubbling, just like they do at Red Lobster. So, go on, don’t hold back, and dive right in!

Ingredients Required for the Copycat Red Lobster Stuffed Mushrooms Recipe

Alright, let’s kick things off by gathering up all the ingredients we’re gonna need. We’ve got a blend of tasty and flavorful crab, fresh veggies, and some choice seasonings to pull it all together. Keep reading to get into the nitty-gritty of the essential ingredients.

Main Ingredients

Our main ingredients for this Red Lobster copycat recipe are simple, but so important. You’ll require 2 tbsp of chopped celery, 1 tbsp of chopped onion, and another tbsp of chopped red bell pepper. Add a touch of 1 cup of goldfish crackers to pet the crunch, and ½ cup of mild cheddar to please your cheese fans. Now, don’t forget to get a good ol’ splash of olive oil ready to grease up the whole deal.

We’ll also need ¼ tsp of garlic powder and the same amount of Old Bay seasoning (trust me, Old Bay seasoning is a superstar in seafood recipes). And yup, don’t forget the MVPs of this dish, the mushrooms and crab claw meat. Grab 15 white mushrooms and ¼ lb of crab claw meat, and you’re all set.

Essential Items for Mushroom Stuffing

Now, button mushrooms are what you want to get your mitts on for this recipe. They’re just the perfect size for stuffing, and they have a kind of neutral flavor that allows the stuffing to shine.

Understanding Ingredient Substitutions

Don’t have crab meat? No problem. You can sub in some mozzarella cheese for a cheesy take on this treat. No button mushrooms at the store? Don’t worry, you can use other similar-in-size mushrooms. With every problem, there’s a delicious solution.

Vegan and Gluten-Free Substitutes

For those plant-eaters out there or folks with gluten things, worry not. Vegan and gluten-free substitutes can slide right into this recipe like a homerun into a baseball glove. Keep an eye out for gluten-free bread crumbs, they’re as common in supermarkets as cats in a post office. These fit right in with vegan recipes too, with no worry of animal stuff getting into your meal. Easy, right?

Complete Guide to Preparing Red Lobster Stuffed Mushrooms

Alright, let’s dive into it. Making a copycat version of Red Lobster’s Stuffed Mushrooms isn’t a walk to the corner store for some Twinkies. But, it’s not like rocket science either. You just gotta know what you’re doing and how to do it. Like building a bike shed, or booking a dentist appointment. Easy peasy.

Preparing the Mushrooms for Stuffing

Now here comes the fun part – prepping the mushrooms. It’s like a pre-party before the big shindig. You got your white buttons, your cremini, your portobello. Each one’s got its own thing going on, ya know what I mean? But hey, whatever mushroom you go with, it’s all about the cleanup. Get all that dirt out of there. Clean those babies up nice and good, you don’t want that stuff ruining the taste. Like making sure the paint’s off before putting up new wallpaper, ya get me?

Making the Perfect Seafood Stuffing

Alright, time for the stuffing mix-up. You’ve got your veggies all nice and cooked up, time to move them over to a bowl. Now you’re gonna add the big guns – crab claw meat, crushed crackers, a little cheddar cheese, some Old Bay seasoning, maybe a hint of garlic powder. Play around with it, like a jazz musician on a keyboard. Once everything’s up to snuff, give it a stir. Not too much, not too little, just enough to get that stuffing mixture singing.

Combining Ingredients for a Balanced Stuffing

So, here’s the layout. You got your 1 cup of chopped onion and ½ cup of chopped red bell pepper, sweating it out in the 2 tbsp of olive oil. Out comes the 1 tbsp of our secret weapon: the Red Lobster copycat recipe, along with a bit of ¼ tsp Old Bay seasoning. Add in your crushed saltine crackers and mild cheddar, and you’re rock and rolling. It’s like conducting a symphony of flavors. The balance is key here, gotta get that right, like a tightrope walker over a canyon.

Texture Tips for Savory Stuffing

Now, texture, that’s the real kicker. It’s what separates the men from the boys, the wheat from the chaff, the stuffing mixture from the crushed crackers. Too thick, and it tastes like a brick. Too thin, and it’s soup. You’re aiming for that Goldilocks zone. Just right, like a well-tailored suit or a comfy pair of sneakers. Pay attention to it, and your stuffing will be as smooth as Sinatra.

Stuffing Your Mushrooms with Precision

Now let’s get down to the nitty-gritty, stuffing those mushrooms. The kind of mushrooms you choose makes a big difference. You’ve got your white button mushrooms, and cremini, or if you’re feeling grand, go for portobello!

But no matter the type, cleanliness is crucial. In the kitchen, it’s all about cleaning away the dirt and grime, especially from the stem of the mushroom. Don’t sleep on this, folks, because you don’t want any grit spoiling the taste of your perfectly stuffed mushrooms.

Baking Tips for Optimal Results

So here’s the scoop my friends, to make the most of your oven and get those mushrooms baked to perfection, you gotta keep a few things in mind. First up, your stuffing. It’s all about balance. Cream cheese for that creamy texture, Monterey Jack for the cheesy goodness, and Red Lobster’s secret seasonings for that kick. Get it all mixed up just right and you’re halfway to mushroom heaven.

But remember, every oven is different, and what works in mine might not work in yours. So keep an eye on those beauties, and when they’re golden and bubbly, you know they’re ready.

Wrapping Up

Well, isn’t that a thing? You just created a mouthwatering batch of Red Lobster stuffed mushrooms right in your kitchen! Made from scratch, no less. Aren’t you a stand-out! Nothing is more satisfying than serving up a delicious appetizer that has everyone at the dinner table hankering for more. And let me tell you, with this recipe, that’s exactly the response you should expect.

Baking this savory goodness may have seemed daunting at first, with all those ingredients to gather and steps to follow. But take it from me, the result is worth more than the effort. Give this recipe a try, you won’t regret it.


Red Lobster Stuffed Mushrooms

Indulge in the exquisite delight of our Red Lobster Stuffed Mushrooms! Let the savory blend of mushrooms, seafood, and rich flavors take your taste buds on a culinary journey.
Prep Time25 minutes
Cook Time20 minutes
Total Time45 minutes
Course: Appetizer, Fancy Appetizer, Quick & Easy, side dishes, Snacks
Keyword: Red Lobster Stuffed Mushrooms
Servings: 15 stuffed mushrooms
Author: The Endless Appetite


  • 2 tbsp chopped celery
  • 1 tbsp chopped onion
  • 1 tbsp chopped red bell pepper
  • 1 cup goldfish crackers
  • ½ cup mild cheddar cheese
  • Splash of olive oil
  • ¼ tsp garlic powder
  • ¼ tsp Old Bay seasoning
  • 15 white button mushrooms
  • ¼ lb crab claw meat


1. Preparing the Mushrooms for Stuffing:

  • Clean the mushrooms thoroughly to remove any dirt.
  • Ensure the mushroom stems are free of grit.

2. Making the Perfect Seafood Stuffing:

  • Sauté chopped celery, onion, and red bell pepper in 2 tbsp olive oil until softened.
  • Add ¼ lb crab claw meat, 1 cup crushed goldfish crackers, ½ cup mild cheddar cheese, ¼ tsp garlic powder, and ¼ tsp Old Bay seasoning to the sautéed vegetables.
  • Stir the mixture until well-combined.

3. Combining Ingredients for a Balanced Stuffing:

  • Sweat 1 cup chopped onion and ½ cup chopped red bell pepper in 2 tbsp olive oil.
  • Add 1 tbsp of the Red Lobster copycat seasoning and ¼ tsp Old Bay seasoning.
  • Incorporate crushed saltine crackers and mild cheddar cheese into the mixture.

4. Texture Tips for Savory Stuffing:

  • Achieve the right texture by balancing the thickness of the stuffing mixture.

5. Stuffing Your Mushrooms with Precision:

  • Clean and prepare the mushrooms for stuffing.
  • Stuff the mushrooms with the seafood stuffing mixture.

6. Baking Tips for Optimal Results:

  • Preheat the oven.
  • Bake stuffed mushrooms until golden and bubbly, approximately 20 minutes.


  • Experiment with different mushroom varieties for unique flavors.
  • Ensure the stuffing is neither too thick nor too thin for the best texture.
  • Keep an eye on the mushrooms while baking to prevent overcooking.

You Might Also Like

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.